Friday, 14 August 2015

More on music in the operating theatre

Roger Watson, Editor-in-Chief

Our recently published article by Weldon et al. (2015) titled: 'Music and communication in the
operating theatre' which features in the previous JAN interactive entry has certainly 'got legs'. Today the altmetrics exceeded 200 and that is in less than one week since publication.

The article featured on the flagship BBC Radio 4 programme Today and this is presented in a podcast. In addition, the first author, Sharon-Marie Weldon, was interviewed on BBC World News.

The issue continues to attract interest and the JAN paper was juxtaposed against a Lancet article this week which reported how soothing music was for patients. Of course, this is all good material for the press as they like the debate and outside of the scientific arena a London based surgeon, Alex Chung, wrote a column in The Daily Telegraph of 14 August 2015 where he took a sarcastic angle on the JAN article and made it clear - revealing his arrogance in the process - that in the operating theatre his 'choices ruled'. He must be a real pleasure to work with!

What are your views on music in the operating theatre? Post them here, write an entry or Tweet us and remember to include the link to the article by Weldon et al. (2015).


Weldon. S-M., Korkiakangas. T., Bezemer, J. and Kneebone. R. (2015) Music and communication in the operating theatre. Journal of Advanced Nursing, doi: 10.1111/jan.12744

Wednesday, 5 August 2015

Is music in the operating theatre dangerous?

Roger Watson, Editor-in-Chief

Music is played during the majority of operations performed in operating theatres (OTs) and has been playing in OTs almost since it was possible to have portable music devices. Admittedly, some may nor seem that portable these days and with increasing portability has come increasing frequency of music being played and an increasing variety of the music being played.

Originally music in OTs was meant to benefit patients by creating a relaxing ambience as they were anaesthetised and, according to patients in at least one study, they like it (Stevens 1990).  According to another study, it does reduce pre-operative anxiety (Cooke et al. 2005).  However, there is an assumption that such music is soothing, suitable to a broad taste in music and not having any unexpected adverse consequences.

Apart from the fact that one person's music can be another person's torture, what if music is not soothing, but loud and intrusive?  Can this have adverse consequences?  According to a recent study conducted at Imperial College London by Weldon et al. (2015) titled: Music and communication in the operating theatre and published in JAN, it can. Music can be so loud and intrusive that it hampers staff communication and good communication in  the OT is essential for patient safety both in terms of speed and accuracy of information exchange, requests and instructions.

In the study by Weldon et al. video recordings were made of operations with and without music and the speed - in terms of how often things had to be repeated - of communication was observed and recorded.  In the presence of music the speed of communication was decreased as people had to ask for information to be repeated.

OTs are already noisy environments and the noise levels exceed recommended safety limits.  The addition of music which, by virtue of the already high background noise has to be played loud, adds to the problem.  According to the authors: 'This study has identified serious patient safety issues that cannot be ignored.  Regardless of whether music can increase surgeons' concentration and mask extraneous noise, anything that might impair team communication might place patients' safety in jeopardy.'  As a recommendation they say: 'We recommend that nurses join the discussion and debate around this topic that is currently heavily represented by the views of surgeons.'

You can listen to this as a podcast.


Weldon. S-M., Korkiakangas. T., Bezemer, J. and Kneebone. R. (2015) Music and communication in the operating theatreJournal of Advanced Nursing, doi: 10.1111/jan.12744

Cooke, M., Chaboyer, W., Schluter, P. and Hiratos, M. (2005), The effect of music on preoperative anxiety in day surgery. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 52: 47–55.

Stevens, K. (1990), Patients' perceptions of music during surgery. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 15: 1045–1051. 

Tuesday, 4 August 2015

World Breastfeeding Week

To mark World Breastfeeding Week, we invited Professor Julie Jomeen, Dean of the Faculty of Health and Social Care at the University of Hull, to select a few of the most important papers on breastfeeding published recently in JAN.

Julie Jomeen

Promotion of breastfeeding (BF) is a public health priority at an international level, yet many countries fail to enhance sustained BF rates and reach the WHO target of exclusive breastfeeding for six months. Many factors are acknowledged to influence intention, initiation and continued BF. In recognition of World Breastfeeding Week and, in the US, National Breastfeeding Month, I have selected five papers to discuss in this blog, published in JAN since 2013 that explore factors that might be influential to BF outcomes.

Artieta-Pinedo et al (2013) explore the association between attendance at antenatal education sessions and BF across the first postnatal year. The study was undertaken in Spain, where antenatal education is free to all women. Using a prospective observational design, 614 women were classified into 3 groups according to the level of education sessions received (0; 1-4; >5); telephone interviews assessed risk of cessation up to 12 months. Despite a 90% initiation rate across groups, by one month there was a dose response relationship between BF and level of attendance. However, there were no statistically significant differences between groups at 6 or 12 months. The authors suggest BF continuation for the first postnatal month was linked to greater awareness of physical changes and BF problems, gained through the antenatal education sessions. Sustained rates were less influenced, but the authors suggest may still be related to modifiable antecedents.

Wu et al (2014) explore BF self-efficacy as one such potential variable and sought to examine the effect of a self-efficacy intervention in Chinese mothers. In a pre-post test two group design, participants in the intervention group showed significantly greater increases in both BF exclusivity and duration than those in the control group. This study is limited by a small sample and that findings relate to short rather than long term outcomes, although results are promising enough to warrant further investigation. This paper successfully highlights that understanding the role of psychological aspects on BF initiation and duration as important to improving rates and supporting new mothers.

Brown (2014) sought to explore associations between BF duration and maternal personality; attitudes and experiences. Personality has been shown to be associated with characteristics such as self-efficacy as well as confidence and locus of control. Using a cross sectional survey design, 602 mothers with infants of 6-12  months competed self-report measures  for all variables. Women with high levels of conscientiousness were more likely to initiate BF, with extroversion and emotional stability both significantly associated with both initiation and longer duration of BF. These women were generally more confident in BF. Women who were more introverted were more likely to stop BF due to embarrassment and feeling pressured to stop. Mothers who were more anxious reported greater difficulty and lack of support. Lower conscientiousness was associated with greater body image concerns and pain. The author suggest that self-efficacy interventions may play a role in supporting women with introverted and anxious personality types, as well as interventions to increase maternal support.

Understanding potential modifiable factors that may be of importance in supporting BF initiation and continuation is useful, yet other influential factors have also been identified. Brown and Jordan (2013) explored the role of birth complications in BF cessation. In an exploratory cross-sectional design using an online survey the researchers found that women who experienced birth complications had shorter BF duration. Specifically, caesarean birth, foetal distress, failure to progress and postpartum haemorrhage were significant, due to associated pain and physical difficulties. Whilst these exploratory findings are limited by data collection methods and sample size, they raise interesting questions about targeted BF support for ‘at risk’ women. Whilst the causality here appears to be related to physical consequences, the authors suggest a potential link between physical complications and the psychological effects of birth complications on BF consequences, which may exacerbate low BF rates.

The recent paper by Spencer et al (2015) presents fascinating qualitative findings, which may illuminate the mismatch between BF initiation and continuation rates that international statistics and academic literature continue to demonstrate. The overarching theme that emerged from the data was ‘illusion of compliance’. Women described pressure to initiate BF to comply with ‘good mother’ discourse and conform to the moral obligation to BF, hiding the difficulties they encountered to avoid being labelled ‘a failure’. Successful BF to women did not mean exclusive BF; differing constructions of meaning led to women turning away from healthcare professionals. This paper raises important questions for healthcare professionals about their content and approach to providing interventions for women in support of BF.

Together these papers and many others published in JAN and elsewhere remind us that what would seem a simple and natural health behaviour may not be in our increasingly complex world. However, and despite challenges to achievement, international goals for BF or, at the least, breast milk provision to the world's children are important and worth the support of all who advocate for a healthier world.

Julie Jomeen is a qualified nurse and midwife, who has worked at all clinical levels and also in a practice development role within a women and children’s health department of a large acute trust, currently working as Dean: Faculty of Health and Social Care, University of Hull. Julie remains involved in both pre and post-registration teaching and post-graduate research supervision. Research interests focus on issues around women’s health and maternity care with particular interest in psychological/mental health across the maternity spectrum and choice in healthcare, evidenced by numerous national and international publications and conference presentations.

Isabel Artieta-Pinedo, Carmen Paz-Pascual, Gonzalo Grandes, Amaia Bacigalupe and Janire Payo

Amy Brown

Amy Brown and Sue Jordan

Rachael L. Spencer, Sheila Greatrex-White and Diane M. Fraser

Di Shi Wu, Jie Hu, Thomas P. McCoy and Jimmy T. Efird